One of the most common problems in woodworking finishing applications is swirl mark, also known as fish hooks. This is a complaint that cuts across a one-person cabinet shop on up to large manufacturing plants, and can result in a reworking of the product and increased costs.
In determining the causes and solutions, it is useful to evaluate four main factors in the finishing process: the air compressor(s); the shop’s random orbit sanders; operator training; and the sanding disc.
The first question to ask: Is your shop compressor designed to do the job you are needing it to do? An air compressor can only be as effective as the clear and sufficient air that is supplied to the relevant air tool.
I sometimes see shops still using the original compressor with which they began their business. Yet production needs may have increased or changed. Perhaps additional air tools have been added increasing the drain on the CFMs and PSIs from the compressor. The layout of the shop may have changed, affecting the delivery system of air from the compressor to the workstation. It is important to check the supply line for routing, distance, length, diameter and kinks to ensure a maximum air supply.
Another common compressor problem is air leaks. Compressor manufactures estimate that many shops, no matter the size of the shop, may have up to 25 percent air leaks. Air leaks affect both the CFMs and PSIs required for maximum tool performance, which in turn can result in swirl marks. Also, compressor air is considered the third utility behind electric and gas. Air leaks increase costs.
Random orbit sanders
Random orbit sanders require from 8.5 to 17 CFMs per unit. They offer a speed range of 13,000 to 12,000 RPMs, with a DB rating ranging from the upper 70s to the middle 80s. The operator has a choice of 3/32, 5/16, 3/16/,3/8 random orbit patterns.
The sander itself may contribute to swirl marks for a number of reasons. It may not be receiving enough air to operate at peak performance (see air compressors above). The DA pad may have cracked edges or under-sizing caused by excessive wear; a worn DA pad, or one with excessive dirt or glue buildup, can lead to swirl marks or other finishing problems. Often, swirl problems are quickly resolved by simply replacing the DA pad.
An often overlooked is operator training – and retraining. This is helpful for maintaining a quality end product as well as for operator safety. It may be useful to have operators perform a quality tool checklist at the beginning of their shifts which could include: examining DA pads for undersizing, cracks from wear or build up from dirt or glue; and checking to ensure sanders are balanced and running smoothly. Be aware of excessive sander vibration, which causes white knuckles, and for possible bearing or air leak noise. These symptoms usually indicate a serious problem with the tool.
Keep a list handy of operator tips. These could include: starting the sander on the part and walking the running tool off the part can remove swirl marks. To increase smooth running and tool life, operators should place a drop or two of air tool oil through the air fitting, connect the hose, and run the sander for a short time at the beginning of their shift. In turn, at the end of the shift, use a blow nozzle to remove dust build up from under the shroud and pad.
Finally, we come to what is usually blamed for the swirl mark problem—the sanding disc. Sanding discs come in a rainbow of colors. The color, however, serves no purpose in identifying usage, function, quality, etc.; one manufacture has the same color discs that serve five different functions. The bottom line is not all woodworking style discs serve the same function just because the color is the same across different manufacturers. In other words—Don’t judge a disc by its color.
Beyond the grit, size, and number of holes, what also has an impact is the disc backing. Backings can be made of any number of materials including paper, Velcro, HD paper, cloth and film. In turn, the backing material can vary by thickness, adhesive bonding and ability to withstand heat from random orbit tool sanding procedures. There is no industry standard.
Disc surfaces also can vary by types of minerals and/or blends. Aluminum oxide (and blended other minerals) has been accepted in all areas of wood working production for many years. Most disc surfaces contain stearates, which reduce sanded material from sticking to the disc during the stock removal. However, even though stearates differ among manufactures, they should not contribute to swirl marks.
Source: Tim Churchill is the president of TGM Sales, a manufacturer’s representative of woodworking tools in Missouri. For more information contact [email protected].
Have something to say? Share your thoughts with us in the comments below.